The Cottage Smallholder

stumbling self sufficiency in a small space

Old Fashioned Apple Jelly Recipe

A green cooking apple growing in our garden

A green cooking apple

This morning I decided to make apple jelly with the apples that our friend Anne Mary gave us last week. They are now in the jelly bag, left to drip for the rest of the day. (What is a “jelly bag”? See tips and tricks below).

We always use cooking apples for apple jelly so that it is not too sweet and much more adaptable. For years I only thought of jelly as an accompaniment to meat. The jars opened and enjoyed but usually lost in the depths of the fridge. I cringe now at the thought of the great jellies that must have been wasted on us.

Over the past couple of years we have begun to discover the breadth of the jelly repertoire. Initially, we worked hard trying to make jelly with a good flavour, rather than the ultra sweet stuff that I remember as a child. I asked all my clients for tips. Armed with this unique knowledge, (most of them are good, inventive cooks) and a lot of experimentation we have finally made a small range of jellies that we think are good. This delicate apple jelly is one of the stars.

As we had all these pots of jelly crowding out the larder we were forced to become adventurous. We found that a decent dollop of a stronger jelly in a stew lifted the flavours. We ate it with cheese. We used it in casseroles, as a sauce base for pork and chicken and stirred it into hearty winter soup. We even tried in stir fries (great with a chicken or duck.

We found that dark meat and game cry out for a slightly stronger jelly, such as our damson or wild plum. We also make a punchy sloe and Bramley jelly which adds an extra fillip to a pheasant or venison dish. If we run out of the more raunchy jelly, Danny adds a slug of sloe gin, although I prefer the sharper fruity effect of damson gin. A dash of sloe or damson gin is super in stews, sauces and gravy. You can’t taste the alcohol, just a deep, mellow flavour.

Old Fashioned Apple Jelly Recipe


  • 4 pounds/1.8 kilos of cooking apples (windfalls are fine for this recipe)
  • 2 UK pints/1140ml/5 cups of water
  • Grated rind and juice of one large lemon
  • White granulated sugar (the amount depends on the volume of juice extracted from the simmered, drained fruit. 1 pint/500ml/2 1/2 cups of juice to 1 pound/454gms of sugar. I always make sure that I have a 2 kilo bag of sugar in the larder, just in case I fancy making jelly)


  1. Wash the apples, cut out bad bits and chop roughly. There is no need to peel and core the apples.
  2. Carefully grate the lemon zest from the lemon (we use a zester but a fine grater will do. Try to avoid including the pith as this would make the jelly bitter).
  3. Place fruit and lemon zest in a large deep heavy bottomed saucepan, or preserving pan. Add the water and bring gently Bring gently to the boil and simmer very gently until all the fruit is soft and mushy (roughly 25 minutes, depending upon how ripe the fruit is).
  4. Pour the cooked fruit through sterilised muslin. (How do I sterilise muslin? See tips and tricks below). The muslin is often referred to as a “jelly bag”. We use tall buckets to catch the drips from the jelly bags. Rather than hang the bags (conventional method-between two stools) I find it easier to line a large plastic sieve with the muslin. This clips neatly onto the top of a clean bucket. The sieve is covered with a clean tea cloth to protect against flies, as the jelly bag generally drips overnight.
  5. Measure the apple juice the next day and pour it into a deep heavy bottomed saucepan. Add 454g/1 pound of white granulated sugar for each 570ml/1 pint/2 1/2 cups of juice.
  6. Add the juice of the lemon.
  7. Heat the juice and sugar gently, stirring from time to time. Make sure that that all the sugar has dissolved before bringing the liquid slowly to the boil. Continue to boil for about five minutes before testing for a set. (What is testing for a set? See tips and tricks below).
  8. Toss in a nugget of butter towards the end to reduce the frothing that often occurs.
  9. When jelly has reached setting point pour into warm sterilised jars using a funnel and ladle. (How do I sterilise jars? See tips and tricks below).
  10. Cover immediately with plastic lined screw top lids or cellophane tops secured with a rubber band.
    Label when cold and store in a cool, dark place. Away from damp. (My jelly is too liquid. See Tricks and tips below)

Tips and tricks:

  • What is a jelly bag?
    A jelly bag is traditionally a piece of muslin but it can be cheesecloth, an old thin tea cloth or even a pillowcase. The piece needs to be about 18″ square. When your fruit is cooked and ready to be put in the jelly bag, lay your cloth over a large bowl. Pour the fruit into the centre of the cloth and tie the four corners together so that they can be slung on a stick to drip over the bowl. Traditionally a stool is turned upside down, the stick is rested on the wood between the legs and the jelly bag hangs over the bowl. We experimented and now line a sieve with muslin, place it over a bucket and cover the lot with clean tea cloths (against the flies).
  • How do I sterilise muslin/the jelly bag?
    Iron the clean jelly bag with a hot iron. This also works with tea cloths.
  • What is Jam “set” or “setting point”?
    Getting the right set can be tricky. I have tried using a jam thermometer but find it easier to use the following method. Before you start to make the jam, put a couple of plates in the fridge so that the warm jam can be drizzled onto a cold plate (when we make jam we often forget to return the plate to the fridge between tests, using two plates means that you have a spare cold plate). Return the plate to the fridge to cool for approx two minutes. It has set when you run your finger through it and leave a crinkly track mark. If after two minutes the cooled jam is too liquid, continue to boil the jam, testing it every few minutes until you have the right set. The jam is far more delicious if it is slightly runny.
  • How do I sterilise jam jars?
    We collect jars all year round for our jelly, chutney and jam making sessions. I try to soak off labels and store the clean jars and metal plastic coated screw-top lids in an accessible place. The sterilising method that we used is simple. Just before making the jam, I quickly wash and rinse the jars and place them upside down in a cold oven. Set the temperature to 160c (140c fan-assisted). When the oven has reached the right temperature I turn off the heat. The jars will stay warm for quite a while. I only use plastic lined lids for preserves as the all-metal lids can go rusty. I boil these for five minutes in water to sterilise them. If I use Le Parfait jars, I do the same with the rubber rings.


  Leave a reply


  1. Fiona Nevile

    Hi Nicoletta

    I’m afraid that I can’t advise you on how to dry apples.

    Apple jelly is delicious. Also apple wine and cider would be worth considering. Chutney is good too.

    We freeze apple puree for the winter.

  2. Nicoletta

    I have just found your site. Wonderful! Can you give me an idea on how to dry my James Grieve apples?
    Or how to cope with this huge crop from one beautiful and very old tree that, because I now live in Italy, tends to drop the apples by the minute.
    I suppose James Grieve do better in colder climate.

  3. Fiona Nevile

    Hi Irene,

    Great idea to add some cloves to the apples. I must try this. Mashing down the softened fruit is fine. Squeezing the jelly bag can cause problems though.

    Thanks for dropping by and leaving a comment.

  4. Hey,

    I always add some whole cloves to the apples before simmering as it gives a glorious flavour to the jelly. I also then mash down the softened fruit. Should I not do this? any ideas?


    • Sussex Oldest Family Recipe

      If you touch the fruit by mashing it, it cause the jelly to become cloudy – l would advise not to….?

  5. Fiona Nevile

    Hi LizO,

    I must try adding a little vinegar to my herb jelly. Thanks for the tip.

  6. Hi
    Just made mint and apple jelly with a little added vinegar which has worked extremely well, even though I used dried mint because my mint in the garden needs another year to produce a really good harvest. I also found a Chilli & Apple jelly recipe from Worrell-Thomson which also worked well though could have had a bit more chilli to give it more of a kick!
    Thanks for your help
    LizO :o)

  7. Fiona Nevile

    Hi LizO,

    I can read my emails at work on my phone but can’t comment until I am on my home computer. So often queries hang in the air for a few hours.

    Thanks for saying thank you. Much appreciated.

  8. I found the Francoise recipe after I had asked you what you thought and I have to say that it pretty well answered my query. Anyway I’ll let you know how I get on and what new flavours I discover. Well done Cottage Smallholders, what a find to have found your site – absolutely the best – I haven’t opened a recipe book since I found you so thank you very much! :o)

  9. Fiona Nevile

    Hi LizO,

    Of course you can add anything that you want. I left this apple recipe plain as I originally made it with some wonderful dessert apples that Anne Mary gave me. I knew from her twinkle that they were special and the jelly was wonderful. Unfortunately I can’t remember the name of the apples.

    If I was using the eating apples from our garden I would definitely add some other flavours as they are at the lower end of the eating apple taste bracket. Have you seen the post Francoise™s garden herb jelly recipe?
    This jelly is very good and pretty too.

  10. Good recipe and I will make juice tomorrow and then jelly. Can I add flavouring to this such as mint or chilli flakes?
    LizO :o)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags are not allowed.

2,238,051 Spambots Blocked by Simple Comments

Copyright © 2006-2022 Cottage Smallholder      Our Privacy Policy      Advertise on Cottage Smallholder